What Makes an Exceptional Dental Office Manager?

Industry Leaders Speak

The Reality Check

Coming Up

In the following sections, we'll dive deep into:

• Core traits and how to spot them
• Interview strategies that work
• Practical evaluation methods
• Real-world success stories

8 Dental Office Manager Traits That Make or Break Business

1. Common Sense & Compassion

[Credited to Tara R. Klein, Practice Manager]

Example: A patient arrives for a root canal, visibly anxious, and mentions they lost their job last week.

• Immediately recognize both emotional and financial concerns
• Discuss payment plan options before the procedure
• Ensure the clinical team knows about the patient's anxiety
• Follow up personally after treatment
• Send a thoughtful note with job resources

Key Traits Demonstrated:

• Natural problem-solving abilities without constant supervision
• Emotional intelligence in handling patient concerns
• Ability to make sound decisions under pressure
• Natural empathy towards patient anxiety and concerns
• Balance between business needs and patient care

2. Growth Mindset & Adaptability

[Credited to Martin Mendelson]

Example: During COVID-19, a practice dental office manager:

• Quickly implemented new safety protocols
• Learned and set up teledentistry systems within a week
• Trained staff on new procedures
• Created patient communication systems
• Adapted scheduling to new cleaning requirements

Key Traits:

• Eagerness to learn new dental technologies and procedures
• Openness to feedback and continuous improvement
• Ability to adapt to changing practice needs
• Interest in dental industry trends and updates
• Proactive approach to professional development

3. Relationship Building

[Credited to Bob Crowley, All-star Contributor]

Example: A new patient with a bad previous dental experience leaves a negative review.

• Personally calls to understand their concerns
• Schedules a face-to-face meeting
• Creates a customized comfort plan
• Turns them into a practice advocate
• Patient ends up referring family members

Key Traits:

• Natural ability to connect with patients quickly
• Strong team leadership capabilities
• Conflict resolution skills
• Ability to build trust with staff and patients
• Excellence in internal and external communication

4. Business Acumen & Sales Ability

[Credited to Ori Bekerman]

Example: A practice was struggling with low case acceptance for dental implants.

• Analyzed past presentation methods and identified gaps
• Created a patient education program using visual aids
• Trained staff on discussing financing options
• Implemented follow-up protocols
• Result: Implant case acceptance increased from 45% to 78% in 3 months

Key Traits:

• Understanding of dental practice metrics
• Ability to increase case acceptance rates
• Financial conversation skills
• Insurance and billing knowledge
• Revenue growth mindset

5. Leadership & Team Management

Example: During a staff shortage crisis, the dental office manager:

• Created a cross-training program
• Developed emergency coverage protocols
• Maintained full schedule while short-staffed
• Built team morale through recognition programs
• Result: Zero patient complaints despite being understaffed

Key Traits:

• Staff training and development abilities
• Delegation and task management skills
• Team motivation capabilities
• Crisis management skills
• Ability to maintain team morale

6. Technical & Administrative Excellence

Example: A practice facing insurance claim denials averaging $20,000/month.

• Audited rejected claims patterns
• Implemented pre-authorization protocols
• Created staff training on documentation
• Set up weekly insurance verification systems
• Result: Reduced denials by 85% within 2 months

Key Traits:

• Proficiency in dental practice management software
• Understanding of HIPAA and compliance requirements
• Schedule optimization abilities
• Insurance verification expertise
• Documentation and record-keeping skills

7. The X-Factor Qualities

Example: During a power outage mid-treatment:

• Manager had already established emergency protocols
• Backup generator was maintained and ready
• Emergency lighting was immediately activated
• Patients were kept calm and informed
• Treatments completed successfully without interruption

Key Traits:

• Initiative to solve problems before they escalate
• Ability to anticipate needs (the “mind reading” quality noted by Ashish Dham)
• Natural leadership presence
• Calm under pressure
• Innovation in practice improvement

8. Cultural Fit & Personal Attributes

Example: A practice struggling with team turnover.

• Instituted monthly team building events
• Created career development paths
• Started morning huddle traditions
• Implemented employee recognition program
• Result: Zero turnover in following 18 months

Key Traits:

• Professional appearance and demeanor
• Positive attitude and energy
• Reliability and punctuality
• Strong work ethic
• Alignment with practice values

Evaluation Methods for Dental Office Manager Candidates

1. Skills Assessment Matrix

Framework:

• Technical Skills (25%)
• Leadership Abilities (25%)
• Soft Skills (25%)
• Cultural Fit (25%)

Example: A practice in Boston increased their successful hire rate by 60% using this matrix. They previously focused 70% on technical skills, leading to high turnover due to personality conflicts.

2. Staged Evaluation Process

Stage 1: Initial Documentation Review (Pre-Interview)

• Resume verification
• Reference checks
• Social media presence review
• Professional certifications
• Previous practice track record

Stage 2: Phone Assessment

• Communication style evaluation
• Basic knowledge screening
• Availability and logistics
• Salary expectations alignment
• Initial red flag identification

Stage 3: In-Person Evaluations

Morning Session:

• Formal interview with doctor
• Team interaction observation
• Software competency test
• Treatment presentation role-play

Afternoon Session:

• Shadow current manager/team
• Handle mock patient scenarios
• Participate in team huddle
• Problem-solving exercises

3. Practical Assessment Methods

Software Proficiency Test

• Scheduling system navigation
• Insurance verification process
• Patient record management
• Financial transactions
• Report generation

Communication Assessment

• Patient interaction role-play
• Team meeting facilitation
• Written communication sample
• Phone manner evaluation
• Conflict resolution scenario

4. Team-Based Evaluation

360-Degree Feedback System:

• Front desk team input
• Clinical staff feedback
• Current manager evaluation
• Doctor’s assessment
• Patient interaction feedback

Example: A practice in Denver implemented this system where each team member rated candidates on specific criteria. They found that candidates who scored high with all team members had a 90% success rate.

5. Quantitative Scoring System

Performance Metrics (Score 1–5):

• Technical Knowledge
• Leadership Skills
• Problem-Solving
• Communication
• Cultural Fit
• Previous Experience
• Team Feedback
• Role-Play Performance

Red Flag Scoring (-5 points each):

• Inconsistent answers
• Lack of preparation
• Poor references
• Communication issues
• Unprofessional behavior

6. Working Interview Day

Schedule:

• 8:00 AM: Morning huddle participation
• 9:00 AM: Schedule management
• 11:00 AM: Patient interaction
• 1:00 PM: Team lunch observation
• 2:00 PM: Crisis management scenario
• 4:00 PM: End-of-day reporting

Real-World Story: A California practice reduced their turnover by 75% after implementing a full working interview day, as it revealed candidates' true working styles and team compatibility.

Dental Office Manager: Hiring Red Flags

1. During Resume & Initial Screening – High Turnover Pattern

• Candidate changed 4 practices in 2 years
• Claims "seeking better opportunities" without clear progression
• Blames previous employers consistently
• Vague about reasons for leaving

Inconsistent Career History:

• Unexplained gaps in employment
• Frequent role changes without growth
• Inability to provide clear references
• Job titles don’t align with claimed responsibilities

2. During Interview Process – Communication Issues

Example: A candidate interviewed in Atlanta showed these warning signs:

• Interrupted the interviewer repeatedly
• Used dismissive language about previous staff
• Couldn’t provide specific examples when asked
• Showed poor listening skills during team interactions

Leadership Style Concerns:

• Takes credit for team achievements
• Uses “I” instead of “we” when discussing successes
• Shows authoritarian tendencies
• Dismisses team input in scenarios

3. Professional Knowledge – Outdated or Limited Skills

Red Flag Scenario:

• Unfamiliar with current dental software
• No HIPAA compliance knowledge
• Limited understanding of insurance processes
• Resistance to learning new technologies

Lack of Growth Mindset:

• No continuing education history
• Dismissive of new methodologies
• Unable to adapt during role-play scenarios
• Stuck in “this is how we’ve always done it” mindset

4. Behavioral Warning Signs – Poor Cultural Fit Indicators

Example: A practice in Seattle ignored these signs and faced team exodus:

• Showed different personality with staff vs. doctor
• Made condescending remarks about current systems
• Displayed rigid thinking about processes
• Showed minimal interest in practice culture

Unprofessional Conduct:

• Late to interview without valid reason
• Inappropriate dress or presentation
• Poor email/phone communication
• Speaks negatively about previous employers

5. Reference Check Red Flags – Verification Issues

• Previous employers won’t confirm employment
• References are personal friends only
• Inconsistent dates/roles reported
• Unable to provide direct supervisor references

Performance Concerns – Warning Pattern:

• References are vague about accomplishments
• Hesitation when discussing reliability
• Won’t comment on team relationships
• Mention of policy/procedure violations

6. Team Interaction Warning Signs – Poor Team Chemistry

• Dismissive of support staff
• Shows different personalities with different team members
• Creates tension during group exercises
• Lacks empathy in patient scenarios

Leadership Red Flags – Example Scenario: During working interview:

• Takes over without understanding current processes
• Criticizes before learning systems
• Ignores input from experienced staff
• Shows inflexibility with suggested changes

7. Financial Discussion Concerns – Money Management

• Vague about previous financial responsibilities
• Unable to explain basic metrics
• Uncomfortable with financial conversations
• Poor understanding of practice profitability

Interview Strategies and Questions for Dental Office Manager Hiring

1. Initial Phone Screening Questions

Purpose: Filter candidates before in-person interviews

• "Describe your experience with dental software systems."
• "What's your approach to handling upset patients?"
• "How do you prioritize tasks during a busy day?"
• "What interests you about our practice specifically?"

2. Scenario-Based Questions

Example: Create a scenario: “It’s Monday morning. Two staff called in sick. The schedule is full. The doctor is running late. A patient is upset in the waiting room.”

• "Walk me through your first 15 minutes."
• "What resources would you tap into?"
• "How would you communicate with various stakeholders?"
• "What preventive measures would you implement for the future?"

3. Leadership Assessment Questions

Behavioral Examples:

• "Tell me about a time you had to fire someone."
• "How did you handle resistance when implementing a new policy?"
• "Describe how you turned around a negative team dynamic."
• "Share an example of mentoring a team member."

4. Financial Acumen Questions

Skills Assessment:

• "How would you handle a patient questioning their bill?"
• "What metrics would you track to measure practice health?"
• "Describe your experience with insurance verification."
• "How do you increase case acceptance rates?"

5. Multi-Stage Interview Process

Real-World Implementation:

• First Interview: Basic qualifications and experience
• Second Interview: Team interaction and culture fit
• Skills Assessment: Software proficiency test
• Final Interview: Meeting with doctor and key team members
• Working Interview: Half-day practical assessment

6. Role-Play Exercises

Practical Scenarios:

• Handle an angry patient (played by team member)
• Present a treatment plan with financial options
• Lead a morning huddle
• Resolve a staff conflict
• Explain insurance benefits to a confused patient

7. Team Involvement

Strategy:

• Have candidates interact with different team members
• Gather feedback from all staff interactions
• Observe how they adapt to different personalities
• Watch their behavior during downtime
• Notice how they treat support staff

8. Cultural Fit Assessment

Key Questions:

• "What type of work environment brings out your best?"
• "How do you prefer to be managed?"
• "What would your ideal practice culture look like?"
• "How do you contribute to positive workplace culture?"